The Best Indestructible Dog Toys

All dogs should have toys to play with, but when your four-legged friend destroys any toy you buy within minutes, you may feel like it’s futile. Opt for indestructible dog toys, however, and they’ll last your canine companion far longer. Of course, no dog toy is truly indestructible, but we have some options that will slow down the most aggressive of chewers and may last for weeks or months, rather than seconds.

We reviewed dozens of indestructible dog toys to identify the best of the best. To find those products that are worth your hard-earned cash, we compared a variety of factors, including toy type, material, size, and average reviews from existing customers. 

Best Indestructible Dog Toy Overall
Monster K9 Dog Toys Ultra-Durable Ring
An impressively tough ring-shaped chew toy that stands up to hefty wear and tear.

It took some in-depth research but we ultimately chose the Monster K9 Dog Toys Ultra-Durable Ring as our top pick overall. It’s made only from natural rubber and FDA approved materials, so you can be certain it’s safe for your dog. Plus, it can hold its own with the most aggressive chewers.

The 5 Top-Rated Indestructible Dog Toys

Editor’s PicksBrandRating
Best Indestructible Dog Toy OverallMonster K9 Dog Toys Ultra-Durable Ring4.7
Best Indestructible Dog BallKONG Extreme Ball Dog Toy
4.7
Best Budget Indestructible Dog ToyNylabone Flavor Frenzy Power Chew Dog Toy4.3
Best Indestructible Dog FrisbeeHyperflite Jawz Competition Dog Disc4.4
Best Indestructible Dog Chew ToyPet Qwerks Dinosaur BarkBone Chew Toy4.4

*Ratings are from Amazon at the time of publication and can change

Best Indestructible Dog Toy Overall: Monster K9 Dog Toys Ultra-Durable Ring

Want a versatile and super rugged toy for your dog? Consider the Monster K9 Dog Toys Ultra-Durable Ring. Your dog can use it as a general chew toy, but the ring shape is also conducive to games of tug either with a human or another dog. If you’re concerned about whether or not it will be tough enough for your dog, this rubber toy has been tested and approved by a range of strong chewers, including pitbulls, mastiffs, and German shepherds. Buyers rave about how long it lasts their avid chewers, but it’s worth noting that determined dogs can bite chunks off, so you should always supervise your four-legged friend with this toy.

This toy is made from a mixture of natural rubber and synthetics, but all materials used are FDA approved, and the toy itself is tested by a third party lab to prove it’s safe and non-toxic. If you think your dog would like one of these toys, it will cost you just under $21.

Monster K9 Dog Toys Ultra-Durable Ring Key Features:

  • Lifetime replacement guarantee if your dog manages to chew through it
  • Plenty of bounce, so it’s fun for dogs to fetch or toss around
  • Measures approximately 6.5 inches in diameter

Best Indestructible Dog Ball: KONG Extreme Ball Dog Toy

Best Indestructible Dog Ball
KONG Extreme Ball Dog Toy
Thanks to its puncture-proof design, this ball will last through countless games of fetch.

Some dogs love chasing balls but would rather take the ball away and chew it for a while than bring it straight back to you. Unlike tennis balls and other flimsier offerings, the KONG Extreme Ball Dog Toy is designed to resist puncture and other damage from even the most aggressive chewers. Crafted from KONG’s toughest black natural rubber formula, there’s no doubt that this ball was made to last. What’s more, it bounces well and is fun for dogs to chase after.

This ball has a hole through the center, which is great for threading a rope through to improve the distance you can throw it. You can also stuff it with natural peanut butter or similar to keep your dog entertained. It comes in two sizes: small for dogs up to 20 pounds and medium/large for dogs up to 65 pounds. The small ball costs $10, while the large costs $14.

KONG Extreme Ball Dog Toy Key Features: 

  • Crafted from the toughest KONG rubber formula
  • Made in the USA
  • Extremely long-lasting, even for heavy chewers

Best Budget Indestructible Dog Toy: Nylabone Flavor Frenzy Power Chew Dog Toy

Best Budget Indestructible Dog Toy
Nylabone Flavor Frenzy Power Chew Dog Toy
This rugged nylon chew bone is an affordable choice for the most determined chewers.

Belonging to Nylabone’s Power Chew range, the Nylabone Flavor Frenzy Power Chew Dog Toy is designed for dogs with an extreme chewing style. As long as you stick to the correct weight guidelines, your dog won’t be able to bite any chunks off this toy. Instead, tiny pieces (no bigger than a grain of rice) shed off as your dog chews. Your dog can digest these without trouble, though you’ll likely find most end up on the floor, couch, or wherever your dog is chewing.

Thanks to the textured design (and the fact your dog will make the bone even more textured as she chews), this Nylabone can help disrupt plaque and minimize tartar buildup. This makes it an excellent addition to your dog’s oral hygiene routine along with dental chews and tooth brushing.  It comes in two flavors (beef jerky and Philly cheese steak) to make it even more appealing for dogs to chew. Depending on the size and flavor combo you choose, it can cost anywhere between $7 and $12, which we think is extremely reasonable.

Nylabone Flavor Frenzy Power Chew Dog Toy Key Features: 

  • Available in three sizes
  • Textured areas help to keep teeth clean
  • Made in the USA

Best Indestructible Dog Frisbee: Hyperflite Jawz Competition Dog Disc

Best Indestructible Dog Frisbee
Hyperflite Jawz Competition Dog Disc
An ideal choice for chewers who like fetching and catching.

Anyone who’s serious about playing Frisbee with their dog should consider the Hyperflite Jawz Competition Dog Disc. This competition grade disc is more than just a toy; it’s ideal when practicing for competitive dog Frisbee and is aerodynamically designed to allow for impressive long-distance throws. These ultra-tough canine Frisbees are puncture-resistant and ideal when playing with dogs who have put their teeth through disc toys in the past. However, this doesn’t mean they should be used as chew toys.

The dual grip helps experienced Frisbee throwers release just at the right moment to get the perfect trajectory and distance, though you don’t need to be an expert to throw this disc effectively. You can choose between five colors and it will set you back anywhere between $13 and $18, depending on your selection.

Hyperflite Jawz Competition Dog Disc Key Features: 

  • Measures 8.75 inches across
  • Made from high-tech polymers to allow for long-distance throws
  • Suitable for play, practice, or competition use

Best Indestructible Dog Chew Toy: Pet Qwerks Dinosaur BarkBone Chew Toy

Best Indestructible Dog Chew Toy
Pet Qwerks Dinosaur BarkBone Chew Toy
This chunky chew toy will keep even large, enthusiastic chewers from destroying it.

If your dog’s idea of playing is simply chewing on something, give her something she can’t destroy: the Pet Qwerks Dinosaur BarkBone Chew Toy. It’s available in four sizes, the smallest measures 6.5 inches long and is suitable for dogs up to 20 pounds, and the largest measures 11 inches long and is suitable for dogs up to 120 pounds. It’s made from a special nylon blend that, while usually not swallowed, will pass through your dog safely if she ingests small shavings.

Dogs who usually aren’t tempted by chew toys may be encouraged to give it a go, thanks to the tasty natural flavoring. You can choose between either steak or bacon, both flavored using allergen-free food grade ingredients. Depending on the size and flavor you choose, this indestructible chew toy is priced between $7 and $21.

Pet Qwerks Dinosaur BarkBone Chew Toy Key Features: 

  • Made in the USA using safe, non-toxic materials
  • Designed for the most aggressive chewers
  • Can help clean teeth as your dog chews

Who Should Buy an Indestructible Dog Toy

The likelihood is, if you should buy an indestructible dog toy, you’ll already know about it! Indestructible dog toys are for anyone who’s dog is an avid chewer and gets through standard toys in the blink of an eye. Not only will indestructible dog toys save you money, as you’ll need to replace them less frequently, they’ll also be safer for your dog who (hopefully) won’t be able to tear them apart and swallow the pieces.

Best Indestructible Dog Toy Overall
Monster K9 Dog Toys Ultra-Durable Ring
An impressively tough ring-shaped chew toy that stands up to hefty wear and tear.

Important Features to Consider

An indestructible dog toy should have a few important features. Here’s what to consider when selecting an indestructible toy for your dog:

  • Toy type. You’ll find a wide range of types of indestructible dog toys on the market. Popular choices include chew toys, balls, Frisbees, and plus toys. Which your dog will prefer will depend on her likes, dislikes, and play style. It’s likely that your dog will want a few different types of toys to play with.
  • Durability. These toys might be marketed as tough, or indestructible, but not all are equally durable. Manufacturers should give you an idea as to whether toys are designed for the most aggressive chewers or for more moderate chewers. However, you can sometimes get a better idea of how durable a toy is by looking at its customer reviews.
  • Puncture-resistance. Some dog toys are completely puncture-proof or puncture-resistant. If your dog can’t get that first tooth through the outer layer, she’ll be less likely to attempt to destroy it.
  • Size. No matter how tough a dog toy is, if you buy a small toy that’s designed for 20 pound dogs and give it to a 100 pound dog, he’s going to be able to destroy it in no time. As such, always check you’re buying an appropriately sized toy for the size for your dog.
  • Material. Indestructible dog toys are made from materials prized for their durability, such as tough rubber and nylon. You can find some extra-strong plush toys, which may be made from rip-stop fabric, or several layers of fabric to improve durability.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is there a toy my dog can’t destroy?

Your mileage may vary depending on your dog, but there aren’t really any dog toys that are truly indestructible. Most manufacturers avoid using the term “indestructible” directly, and may prefer to call their toys tough, rugged, or durable. However, if you do come across a dog toy that claims to be totally indestructible, this claim is likely too good to be true. That said, some toys come with a lifetime guarantee, so you can get a free replacement if your dog manages to destroy the toy in question.

Why does my dog destroy all her toys?

There’s no single reason why dogs destroy toys but it’s likely down to having a high prey drive, boredom, because they think it’s fun, because they like a challenge, or a combination of these reasons. You may find dogs destroy toys less when presented with puzzle toys or other brain-stimulating activities (though of course supervise your dog so she doesn’t destroy her puzzle toys, too). It might be frustrating, but destroying toys is a perfectly normal canine behavior.

What’s the most durable material for a dog ball?

If you’re looking for the most durable dog ball, we’d recommend we’d recommend looking at solid rubber options.

Should I let my dog destroy her toys?

The problem with allowing dogs to destroy toys is that they can swallow parts they tear or bite off, which can cause dogs to choke or block their intestines. As a result, it’s best not to let your dog destroy her toys. However, if you carefully supervise her and take away any parts that she rips off her toys right away, it’s relatively safe.

Other Indestructible Dog Toys We Reviewed

Best Indestructible Dog Toy Overall
Monster K9 Dog Toys Ultra-Durable Ring
An impressively tough ring-shaped chew toy that stands up to hefty wear and tear.

We looked at 20 other indestructible dog toys. Even though they didn’t make our 5 best indestructible dog toys list, they’re the best of the rest and each is still a great option for your four-legged friend. The information you’ll need to compare each one is included with the listing.

Indestructible Dog Balls

Chew King Fetch Balls

Chew King Fetch Balls

These extra-tough balls are made from natural rubber with a small hollow through the center to reduce the weight and make them less likely to break glass or hurt your dog if your throw goes a little wrong.

Key Features: 

  • Various sizes available
  • Good bounce
  • Stuffable

Cost: $11 to $17

Chuckit Ball Ultra Ball

Chuckit Ball Ultra Ball

The “Ultra” range of Chuckit balls represent some of the toughest from this brand, standing up to aggressive chewers.

Key Features: 

  • Compatible with Chuckit ball launchers
  • Floats in water
  • High bounce

Cost: $15

Monster K9 Dog Toys Indestructible Dog Ball

Monster K9 Dog Toys Indestructible Dog Ball

You’d be hard-pressed to find a dog that can chew their way through this solid natural rubber ball.

Key Features: 

  • Baseball sized
  • Non-toxic
  • Lifetime replacement guarantee

Cost: $20

Monster K9 Dog Toys Indestructible Dog Football

Monster K9 Dog Toys Indestructible Dog Football

This football-shaped dog ball is perfect for launching way down your yard, though since it’s made from solid rubber, be sure to point it away from any windows.

Key Features: 

  • Lifetime guarantee
  • Tested by aggressive chewers
  • Excellent bounce

Cost: $20

Ruff Dawg Ball Solid Rubber Dog Toy

Ruff Dawg Ball Solid Rubber Dog Toy

With a 2,5 inch diameter, this ball is best suited to smallish dogs, under 40 pounds, but the solid rubber construction makes it highly durable nonetheless.

Key Features: 

  • Made in the USA
  • Comes with a lifetime guarantee
  • Floats in water

Cost: $12

Indestructible Dog Frisbees

KONG Flyer

KONG Flyer

The black “extreme” rubber version is the best for heavy chewers, providing a soft catching experience while remaining highly durable.

Key Features: 

  • Large 10 inch diameter
  • Throws nicely
  • Soft and flexible

Cost: $15

Monster K9 Dog Toys Indestructible Dog Frisbee

Monster k9 Dog toys Indestructible Dog Frisbee

With its lifetime replacement guarantee, you can be sure this rubber Frisbee will go the distance.

Key Features: 

  • Made from a tough rubber formula
  • Gentle on dogs’ mouths
  • Smooth surface for improved flying

Cost: $15

Outward Hound BIONIC Toss N’ Tug Durable Fetch and Chew Toy

Outward Hound BIONIC Toss N' Tug Durable Fetch and Chew Toy

This non-standard Frisbee can also double as a tug toy or even a chew toy and is made from tough synthetic rubber.

Key Features: 

  • Free from BPA and phthalates
  • Floats on water
  • Three color choices

Cost: $8

West Paw Zogoflex Zisc Durable Dog Frisbee

West Paw Zogoflex Zisc Durable Dog Frisbee

Virtually indestructible, this canine Frisbee is available in two sizes (6.5 or 8.5 inch diameter) and five colors.

Key Features: 

  • Soft on the mouth
  • Flies well
  • Dishwasher safe

Cost: $10 to $17

Indestructible Dog Chew Toys

Arm & Hammer Super Treadz Dental Chew Toy

Arm & Hammer Super Treadz Dental Chew Toy

Extremely durable chew toys designed to clean your dogs’ teeth as they chew. You can pick between a gorilla or an alligator.

Key Features: 

  • Baking soda-infused for dental health
  • Two sizes available
  • Can be stuffed with treats

Cost: $12

Benebone Real Flavor Wishbone Dog Chew Toy

Benebone Real Flavor Wishbone Dog Chew Toy

This wishbone-shaped chew toys is made from super tough nylon that even the strongest chewers can’t bite chunks off.

Key Features: 

  • Flavorings from real food sources
  • Made in the USA
  • Four size options

Cost: $10 to $20

EETOYS Dog Chew Toys for Aggressive Chewers

EETOYS Dog Chew Toys for Aggressive Chewers

Available in various shapes and sizes, you have plenty of options with these nylon dog chew toys.

Key Features: 

  • Can improve dental health
  • Small, medium, and large sizes
  • Lifetime replacement guarantee

Cost: $11 to $15

GUCHO Ultra Durable Dog Chew Toy

GUCHO Ultra Durable Dog Chew Toy

This soft but tough rubber chew toys is great for dogs who don’t like hard nylon chews. It can also be used for games of tug.

Key Features: 

  • Five inch diameter
  • Textured design helps clean teeth
  • Tested by aggressive chewers

Cost: $14

KONG Tires Extreme Dog Toy

KONG Tires Extreme Dog Toy

Made from KONG’s extreme material, this tire toy is extra tough. The small size is for dogs up to 20 pounds and the large size for dogs 15 to 65 pounds.

Key Features: 

  • Center is stuffable
  • Bounces well when playing fetch
  • Made in the USA

Cost: $11 to $15

Nylabone Big Power Chew XL

Nylabone Big Power Chew XL

These extra-large Nylabones are made for big, powerful chewers over 50 pounds. They become more textured as dogs chew, helping to shift plaque.

Key Features: 

  • Natural shape
  • Flavored all the way through
  • For extreme chewers

Cost: $14 to $17

Nylabone Original Dura Chew Dog Chew

Nylabone Original Dura Chew Dog Chew

Another extra-large Nylabone at an affordable price. This one has plenty of ridges to promote oral hygiene.

Key Features: 

  • Made in the USA
  • Original flavor throughout
  • For large dogs

Cost: $9

Other Indestructible Dog Toys

goDog Checkers with Chew Guard Technology

goDog Checkers with Chew Guard Technology

Chew Guard Technology helps keep this plush toy in one piece for longer, but determined chewers will eventually breach the exterior.

Key Features: 

  • Sized from mini to extra-large
  • Double stitched seams
  • Squeakers and crinkle paper inside

Cost: $8 to $22

Goughnuts TUG MaXX

Goughnuts TUG MaXX

An extra-strong rubber toy designed for playing games of tug, either with two dogs together or a dog and a human.

Key Features: 

  • Soft on dogs’ mouths
  • Measures 11 inches long
  • Chunky and durable

Cost: $28

KONG Tug Toy

KONG Tug Toy

Another toy designed for playing tug. This one isn’t quite as rugged as the Goughnuts offering above but is affordable and stuff fairly tough.

Key Features: 

  • Made from durable natural rubber
  • Approximately 16 inches long
  • Makes it easier to control games of tug

Cost: $15

Outward Hound Invincibles Snake

Outward Hound Invincibles Snake

The reinforced seams help keep dogs from destroying this stuffingless snake toy. Though it’s tough for a plush toy, it’s still nowhere near invincible.

Key Features: 

  • No stuffing means less mess
  • Contains a large number of squeakers
  • Dura-Tuff inner lining

Cost: $8 to $10

Products You May Be Interested In:

Lauren Corona