Poop piles next to the sidewalk or in a park are a no-go. Yet, your dog is going to go when he’s going to go. That makes dog poop bags an absolute necessity for many dog owners. However, have you ever had the wonderful experience of the bag breaking just as you’re picking up the honeypot? Everyone knows all poop bags are not made equal, and you want ones that are easy to use and will hold the goods long term.
We’ve reviewed dozens of dog poop bags to find you the best of the best. We considered features like size, tearing ease (as in how easily it tears away from the next bag on the role), biodegradable, and scented versus unscented bags. You might be surprised to know how many options are really out there. If you’re ready to buy and don’t want to take your chances on bags that break, we’ve researched and reviewed the options to find dog poop bags worth every penny.
The Earth Rated Dog Poop Bags put a checkmark in all of the important boxes. They may not be biodegradable, but their packaging and core are eco-friendly. The 9 x 13-inch size makes them usable for large breeds too. Our favorite feature has to be the extra thick material, which prevents a poop covered hand on your daily walk.
In This Article
The 5 Top-Rated Dog Poop Bags
| Editor's Picks | Brand | Rating |
|---|---|---|
| Best Dog Poop Bags Overall | Earth Rated Dog Poop Bags | 4.8 |
| Best Biodegradable Dog Poop Bags | Doggy Do Good Biodegradable Poop Bags | 4.9 |
| Best Budget Dog Poop Bags | AmazonBasics Unscented Dog Poop Bags | 4.7 |
| Best Extra Strong Dog Poop Bags | Greener Walker Dog Poop Bags | 4.5 |
| Best Scented Dog Poop Bags | AmazonBasics Scented Dog Poop Bags | 4.8 |
*Ratings are from Amazon at the time of publication and can change
Best Dog Poop Bags Overall: Earth Rated Dog Poop Bags
The most important thing a dog poop bag does is hold the poop without breaking, and the Earth Rate Dog Poop Bags definitely have that covered. However, these poop bags offer more than the very basics. For example, they come in lavender-scented or unscented versions. If scented bags leave you nauseated, you get the same reliable quality no matter which version you pick.
These large 9 x 13 inch bags are strong enough to contain the poop of large breeds without breaking. There’s nothing quite like walking home with dog poo on your hands, and that’s not going to happen with these bags. We also like that the company is eco-conscious. While these bags are not biodegradable, they come in recycled packaging and are wrapped around a core made of recycled materials. They come in rolls of 15 bags that fit in Earth Rated and standard dog poop bag dispensers that can attach to your dog’s harness or leash or your belt.
Earth Rated Dog Poop Bags Key Features:
- Dimensions: 9 x 13 inches
- Extra thick
- Scented or unscented options
- Recycled packaging and core
Best Biodegradable Dog Poop Bags: Doggy Do Good Biodegradable Poop Bags
You might think biodegradable means weak and flimsy, but that’s just not the case with the Doggy Do Good Biodegradable Poop Bags. These vegetable-based bags are 20 microns thick, 5 microns more than the standard dog poop bag. Not only are they going to hold a lot of poop, but they’re going hold in the scent, too. Even more important, they’re good for the environment, starting the breakdown process after 90 days.
We like that these bags are easy to open. With some plastic bags, you nearly have to tear through the sides but not with Doggy Do Good. You can open them one-handed and get to picking up immediately.
These bags are a solid 7 x 10 inches, making them big enough for small to mid-sized breeds. If you have a large dog, the Doggy Do Good bags can also be bought in different sizes and with or without handles. We also like that the company donates a portion of sales to animal rescue organizations and no-kill shelters.
Doggy Do Good Biodegradable Poop Bags Key Features:
- Biodegradable and compostable
- Dimensions: 7 x 10 inches
- Comes in different sizes and with or without handles
- Extra thick (20 microns)
Best Budget Dog Poop Bags: AmazonBasics Unscented Dog Poop Bags
The AmazonBasics Unscented Dog Poop Bags come in packages of 270, 300, 540, 600, 810, and 900. You can stock up or get a small box to check them out before a larger commitment. But, we think you’ll be pretty happy with these polyethylene bags. We also like that Amazon provides a plastic dispenser that clips onto a belt loop or leash. However, if you already have a clip, these bags are designed to fit most standard-size dispensers.
They’re 9 x 13 inches, making them big enough for large breeds. Most importantly, they have thicker material for bags at this price, which means they are less likely to break. We also like that they come in a dark color, which hides the stinky contents.
AmazonBasics Dog Poop Bags Key Features:
- Dimensions: 9 x 13 inches
- Comes in different package sizes
- Made of polyethylene
- Affordable price
Best Extra Strong Dog Poop Bags: Greener Walk Dog Poop Bags
No one, and we mean absolutely no one, wants to end up with a handful of dog poop on their evening walk. That’s not going to happen with the Greener Walk Dog Poop Bags. These extra-thick, tough bags can take a heavy load inside their 9 x 13 inches. That’s big enough and strong enough for large breeds.
We can’t help but love the cornstarch-based material. It’s not only eco-friendly but it’s also easier to open than the average plastic poop bag. Plus, their packaging and core are made of recycled materials. The Geener Walk bags also come pre-rolled to fit inside average-sized dispensers that can be clipped to your belt loop or dog’s leash. Finally, each package contains 540 bags, which is enough for up to seven months.
Greener Walk Dog Poop Bags Key Features:
- Dimensions: 9 x 13 inches
- Made of cornstarch-based material
- Extra strong
- Recycled materials used in the packaging and core
Best Scented Dog Poop Bags: AmazonBasics Scented Dog Poop Bags
Most scented poop bags come in a single scent. But the AmazonBasics Scented Dog Poop Bags blow the competition out of the water with four options — Brazilian mango, cucumber, lavender, and talcum powder. Let’s face it; not every scent mixes well with poop. At least with this brand, you’ve got some choices.
These polyethylene bags come in packages of 270, 540, and 810. That gives you some options to choose from before you commit to bulk purchase. The AmazonBasics scented bags measure 9 x 13 inches, which is large enough for those big breeds. They also include a dispenser with a carrying clamp that can attach to your dog’s leash or your belt loop. Finally, these bags easily tear away from the roll, so you’re not fighting a poop bag while trying to control your dog one-handed.
AmazonBasics Scented Dog Poop Bags Key Features:
- Four (4) scents: Brazilian mango, cucumber, lavender, talcum powder
- Dimensions: 9 x 13 inches
- Easy tear-away
Who Should Buy Dog Poop Bags
Dog poop on sidewalks, in public parks, or even in your yard is unsightly and stinky. It can also make it difficult to walk without getting a surprise on the bottom of your shoe. Dog poop bags are easy to carry and use on local trails and sidewalks without your dog leaving behind any special deposits. If you live in an urban area, poop bags are almost a necessity. And even if you don’t, they’re handy to have around.
Some people may recycle plastic grocery bags to use as a poop bag. However, they may have holes you can’t see, and they can be bulky to carry. Dog poop bags are made in rolls small enough to fit in dispensers that you can easily put in your pocket, clip to your belt, or attached to your dog’s leash or collar. Lightweight and portable, you can grab a roll of poop bags on your way out the door without skipping a beat.
Important Features to Consider
Dog poop bags should do several things well. Here’s what to consider when selecting dog poop bags for your next walk:
- Bag size. Dogs are not one size fits all, and neither are poop bags. You’re going to need a significantly larger bag for a Great Dane than you will for a Chihuahua. The largest dog poop bags measure anywhere from 8 to 10 inches by 13 to 15 inches. However, we do have one extra-large model on our list that measures 15 x 20 inches. If your dog is extra-large, definitely look for extra-large, extra-strong bags.
- Material thickness. Most dog poop bags are about 15 microns thick. If the materials are of high quality, that may be enough to contain the poop. Extra thick bags are typically 20 microns, giving your hands 5 extra microns of protection. Owners of big breeds may want to stick with extra strong, thick bags that can handle larger, heavier waste.
- Plastic versus biodegradable. Dog poop bags are typically made of polyethylene (plastic), or a vegetable-based product like a cornstarch-based material that’s biodegradable. Plastic, as you’re probably well aware, does not break down over time and may leave contaminants in the ground or water. Biodegradable, plant-based products, on the other hand, will begin to decompose after about 90 days. Some of them are compostable, so they can add to your compost pile. Sometimes biodegradable bags are more expensive than plastic, but the price difference isn’t usually significant.
- Tie handles. Bags with tie handles are easier to tie closed. However, this type of bag is more expensive. Bags without handles have to be twisted and tied into a knot like a balloon.
- Roll and package size. Price can be deceiving when it comes to dog poop bags. Two bags may appear to be similarly priced, but you have to look at how many bags are on each roll and how many rolls are contained in the package. Most roles have 15 to 24 bags. However, there’s no standard size for how many roles are contained in each package. Pay attention to how much you’re paying per bag to make sure you’re getting a good deal.
Frequently Asked Questions
Are dog poop bags really biodegradable?
Some dog poop bags are biodegradable. These bags are made of plant-based materials, so they break down over time along with the dog’s poop.
Can you flush dog poop bags?
Dog poop bags are not meant to be flushed down the toilet because they can clog plumbing. Please make sure to dispose of them in a proper waste receptacle.
How long do biodegradable dog poop bags take to decompose?
Decomposition can vary by brand and material, but most bags begin to disappear after about 90 days.
Are dog poop bags smell proof?
No bag will be 100 percent smell proof. Thicker bags contain contents better than thin ones, and some bags have a special water-resistant coating on the inside to better contain the contents and the smell. Dog poop bags can contain the smell for a little while, but you should really dispose of the bag in an outside garbage can as soon as possible. Scented poop bags can disguise the smell even longer, although you will eventually be able to smell the poop mixed with the bag’s scent.
Other Dog Poop Bags We Reviewed
We looked at the 20 other dog poop bags. These bags didn’t make our 5 best dog poop bags list, but they’re still some great poop bags worth considering. We’ve included the information you need to compare brands and bags before you buy.
- Biodegradable Dog Poop Bags
- Extra Strong Dog Poop Bags
- Scented Dog Poop Bags
- Dog Poop Bags with Tie Handles
- Unscented Dog Poop Bags
Biodegradable Dog Poop Bags
If you’re looking for a poop bag that will make you laugh, these are the right bags. They come with one of two poop-related sayings.
Key Features:
- Biodegradable
- Easy to separate
- Comes in choice of two (2) sayings
Cost: $13
An odor proof design makes these biodegradable bags a great addition to your walks.
Key Features:
- Odor proof design
- Lavender scented
- Easy tear and separation
Cost: $15
A cornstarch base gives these bags their biodegradability.
Key Features:
- Biodegradable and compostable
- Rose scented
- Unique seal design for durability
Cost: $16
These certified biodegradable dog poop bags easily tear off the roll for one-handed use. A special water-resistant interior coating helps them hold in odors, too.
Key Features:
- Certified biodegradable
- Unscented
- Extra water-resistant interior coating
Cost: $17
These biodegradable bags easily contain poop and fit in standard-size dispensers.
Key Features:
- Includes dispenser and metal carabiner
- Biodegradable
- Double seamed
Cost: $11
An extra interior coating helps lock in waste and odors.
Key Features:
- Includes dispenser
- Easy open design
- Compostable and biodegradable
Cost: $10
UNNI Compostable Dog Poop Bags
These bags may be biodegradable and compostable, but they’re also extra thick for big messes.
Key Features:
- Made of plant starches
- Dimensions: 9 x 13 inches
- Fits standard dispensers
Cost: $17
Yingdelai presents a biodegradable option that’s made for the largest of dogs.
Key Features:
- Dimensions: 9 x 13.5 inches
- Easy tear and separation
- Scented
Extra Strong Dog Poop Bags
Hippo Sak Extra Large Pet Poop Bags
If your dog can dish out more waste than most bags can contain, you need to check these bags out.
Key Features:
- Dimensions: 15 x 20 inches
- Made from recycled materials
- Eight-layer reinforced seal
Cost: $24
For those who like a colorful option, you need to look no further than OUT!.
Key Features:
- Dimensions: 9 x 12 inches
- Includes two dispensing options
- Double seamed bottom
Cost: $20
Poop bags that separate easily won’t tear when you’re getting a new bag, and that’s what these bags do best. That and hold in poop.
Key Features:
- Made of plastic
- Include dispenser
- Metal carabiner
Scented Dog Poop Bags
Best Pet Supplies Dog Poop Bags
The fun designs and colors on these bags might make picking up poop seem not so bad.
Key Features:
- Eleven (11) color and pattern options
- Comes in four (4) package sizes
- Dimensions: 9 x 13 inches
Cost: $7
Petmate Arm & Hammer Disposable Pet Waste Bags
Laced with activated baking soda, these bags have a gentle odor that absorbs the stink.
Key Features:
- Fits standard dispensers
- Comes in several color options
- Twice as thick as a standard grocery bag
Dog Poop Bags with Tie Handles
Bags on Board Hand Armor Dog Poop Bags
The name says it all. The fact that these bags are extra thick, extra-large, and have easy tie handles make them a great option.
Key Features:
- Extra thick design
- Dimensions: 7 x 15 inches long
- Easy tear and separation
Cost: $9
A plant base makes these bags eco-friendly and a great way to get rid of waste.
Key Features:
- Biodegradable and compostable
- Extra thick design
- Double seamed base
Cost: $18
Big dogs need big poop bags, and these 14.5-inch bags are the way to go. They come in a scented or unscented version.
Key Features:
- Dimensions: 7 x 14.5 inches
- Strong tie handles
- Comes in either unscented or powder fresh scent
Cost: $35
ZippyPaws has created bags big enough for the waste of large breeds, and they include easy to tie handles.
Key Features:
- Two (2) color options: green and pink
- Dimensions: 5 x 14.5 inches
- Easy open design
Unscented Dog Poop Bags
EZ Pick Up Pet Waste Disposal Bags
An easy tear design makes these bags simple to use with one hand.
Key Features:
- No core design
- 1,000 bags per package
- Easy tear
Cost: $23
Downtown Pet Supply Dog Waste Poop Bags
When you buy with this company, you buy in bulk. If you want to stock up on poop bags in multiple colors, these are the bags for you.
Key Features:
- Can be bought in 1,000 or 2,200 bag packages
- Easy to separate
- Includes two dispensers
Cost: $23
A simple plastic design makes these reliable poop bags a great choice.
Key Features:
- Three (3) color options: black, blue, green
- Made of plastic
- Includes dispenser
Cost: $15
